Composite vs Wood Decking — Which Is Right for You?

Composite vs wood is the single biggest decision in any deck build. Wood costs less upfront but needs constant care. Composite costs more on day one but often wins over a 20-year horizon. Here's the head-to-head.

Quick Comparison Table

Composite Decking — Pros and Cons

Pros

• Almost zero maintenance — no staining, sealing, or sanding
• Doesn't splinter, warp, rot, or attract termites
• 25–30 year fade-and-stain warranties from major brands
• Consistent color and grain — no "ugly board" lottery

Cons

• 2–3× upfront cost vs pressure-treated
• Can get hot in direct sun (especially darker boards)
• Heavier — more demanding on framing
• Scratches show on premium finishes

Wood Decking — Pros and Cons

Pros

• Lower upfront cost — half or less of composite
• Real wood look and feel
• Easy to repair, sand, or stain a different color later
• Naturally cooler in the sun

Cons

• Requires staining every 2–3 years (~$300–$700 each time)
• Will splinter, warp, and crack over time
• Shorter lifespan — 15–20 years typical
• Susceptible to rot and insects

20-Year Cost of Ownership

For a 200 sqft deck, here's the real math over 20 years:

Composite often comes out slightly ahead — and you save 20+ weekends of staining.

Which Should You Choose?

Pick wood if: you want lowest upfront cost, plan to move within 5–7 years, or love the look of real wood.

Pick composite if: you're staying long-term, hate maintenance, or want a 25+ year warranty.

Run both options through the deck calculator to see your real numbers, or browse the full materials comparison.